All-SCIAC Awards (1982 to present)
# Lee Fulmer Player of the Year
* Freshman of the Year
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 2013 | Bobby Holden | |
| John McCord * | ||
| 2012 | Bobby Holden * | |
| Perry Johnson | ||
| Jeremy Sanders | ||
| 2011 | Jeremy Sanders * | Todd Steller |
| Alex Hedlund | ||
| 2010 | Ross Canavan | Alex Hedlund |
| Ray Biggerstaff | ||
| 2009 | Ross Canavan | Alex Hedlund |
| J.C. Riter | ||
| 2008 | EJ Stenftenagel # | Ross Canavan |
| Scott Pena | ||
| 2007 | EJ Stenftenagel | Nick Giordano |
| Ryan Williams * | ||
| 2006 | Nick Obie # | EJ Stenftenagel |
| R.J. Scholl # | ||
| 2005 | Nick Obie # | Josh Wachtel |
| Chris Nutwell | ||
| R.J. Scholl | ||
| Riley Tolstedt | ||
| Trevor Young | ||
| 2004 | Nick Obie # | Michael Clarke |
| R.J. Scholl | ||
| Trevor Young | ||
| 2003 | Jordan Bailey # | Jim Becker |
| Nick Obie | ||
| Trevor Young | ||
| 2002 | Jordan Bailey # | Jim Becker |
| Ryan Miller | Michael Clarke | |
| 2001 | Michael Clarke | Jordan Bailey |
| Ryan Miller | ||
| 2000 | Jordan Bailey | none |
| Forrest Jones | ||
| 1999 | Forrest Jones | Travis Felder |
| Tres Kirkebo | ||
| 1998 | Travis Felder | Forrest Jones |
| Philip Taube | ||
| 1997 | Travis Felder | Kris Reierson |
| Tres Kirkebo | Wibo Roest | |
| 1996 | John Monfore | Travis Felder |
| Tres Kirkebo | ||
| 1995 | John Monfore | none |
| 1994 | ||
| 1993 | ||
| 1992 | Ron Stockton | Morgan Aggers |
| Dave Jacobson | ||
| 1991 | Bill Reid | Scott Henderson |
| Ron Stockton | ||
| 1990 | Kent Clark | none |
| Roddy Babb | ||
| 1989 | Kent Clark | none |
| Doug Hare | ||
| Scott McCarty | ||
| 1988 | Brian Abbott | Kent Clark |
| Doug Hare | Jim Cope | |
| Scott McCarty | ||
| Rudy Regalado* | ||
| 1987 | Brian Abbott | Kent Clark |
| Rudy Regalado | Jim Cope | |
| Doug Hare | Scott McCarty | |
| 1986 | Jim Cope | Gary Regalado |
| Rudy Regalado* | ||
| 1985 | Brian Abbott* | Greg Mosman |
| Dave Yturri | Gary Regalado | |
| 1984 | Brian Abbott | Jim Light |
| Bob Osborn* | Greg Mosman | |
| 1983 | Bob Osborn | Bucky Gillett |
| Jeff Hopper | ||
| Ray Gail | ||
| 1982 | Bruce Cavarno | John Beall |
| Larry Weiss | ||
| Bob Osborn | ||
